Trends in Islamic Studies in the United States and Canada since the 1970s

Abstract

Islamic studies, like women's studies, Afro-American studies, or
Judaic studies, is a field defined by subject matter rather than a particular
scholarly tradition or disciplinary appmch. However, in m t m t to most
of these other fields, there is scarcely a department of Islamic studies in
Canada or the United States.' Most Islamic studies positions are found
within departments of religious studies and in area studies centers, although
within the latter they are not generally taught by scholars whose
training had a major emphasis on studies of the Islamic religion. It is
misleading to conclude that the study of Islam takes place solely within
Middle East area studies programs, for at this junctm scholarship focusing
on Muslims in other parts of Asia, on Muslim minorities generally,
and on Muslims in North America in particular, is a growing trend.
In terms of scholarly heritage, most of those pursuing Islamic studies
face the same concern felt by the area specialist or the historian of teligion.
In some respects area studies and religious studies have faced similar
challenges. For instance, both foster eclectic theoretical orientations
that can result in either creative synthesis or superficial or "trendy" applications
of the latest methodologies. Both face common dangers: that the
collection and description of data will displace theoretical concerns; the ...