Hyderabad After the Fall by Omar Khalidi; Wichita, Kansas: Hyderabad Historical Society, 1988.

Main Article Content

Krishna D. Mathur

Keywords

Abstract

This is a collection of 13 essays by a group of experts on the society
and politics of Deccani Muslims after Indian independence in 1947. The
readings brought nostalgic memories of men and events I knew or experienced.
"The Five Day War," by Mir Laiq Ali, is a sad commentary on the plight
of Hyderabad forces resisting the Indian offensive that began September 13.
1948.
The Hyderabad case in the U. N. Security Council is described by Clyde
Eagleton, who records the sympathetic response Nizam's representatives
received from most members of the U.N. Council. If Sardar Patel had not
ordered the military occupation of Hyderabad, it is possible that a settlement
could have been reached bet ween Nizam and Nehru. Prof. Zubaida Yazdani
recounts H)derabad's transformation from Niz.arn's Dominion into a state within
India and its breakup on linguitic principle in 1956. Just as innocent Hi ndus
suffered at the hands of Rizakars during 1947-48 , so did innocent Muslims
at the hands of the Indian army after Hyderabad troops surrendered on
September 18, 1948.
Prof. Wilfred C. Smith, a keen observer of the Indian religious scene
for the last five decades, has provided a succinct background upon which
other scholars have built detailed accounts. Dr. Theodore P. Wright, Jr. has
made a fascinating study of minority group politics and concludes that separatist
politics in Hyderabad is more likely to harm the Muslim minority than
potentially benefit it .
Ratna Naidu's research into the Muslims of Bidar, Karnataka, a part of
the old Hyderabad state, provides rare insight into the condition of the Muslim
community in a semi-rural setting. The Joss of privileges is studied by
Rashiduddin Khan and flawlessly woven into a fascinating narrative by Akbar
S. Ahmad, a sociologist, and Usama Khalidi, a journaljst. Zahir Ahmad,
an administrator who worked for both the Hyderabad and Indian governments,
rightly observes that Indian adminstrators have an imperfect understanding
of problems faced by the toiling masses, as most administrators come from
elitist backgrounds.
Finally, Omar Khaljdi has combed through various books and journals ...

Abstract 163 | PDF Downloads 345