Sufism A New History of Islamic Mysticism By Alexander Knysh (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2017. 392 pages.)

Main Article Content

Logan Welch

Keywords

Abstract

Alexander Knysh’s Sufism: A New History of Islamic Mysticism provides a
thorough understanding of Sufism. His detailed chapters break down the
different elements of Sufism, from how the term and practice emerged to
the specific traditions carried out by Sufis.
The first chapter, “How and Why Sufism Came to Be,” contrasts Sufi
Muslims who believe they are supposed to live a frugal lifestyle with other
Muslims who believe they should enjoy all they have in life while remaining
pious. Kynsh focuses heavily on American scholar Marshall Hodgson and
his argument of “temperament”, and Russian Ukrainian scholar Agafangel
Krymskii and his contention that the Sufi sect is a result of socio-economic
conditions. Hodgson claims that Sufism was developed in order that people
practice the piety which complements their temperament. Krymskii claims
that an ascetic-mystical Sufism helped underprivileged people cope with
the historical conditions of the Arab conquests.


Kynsh then considers the various definitions of Sufism in the chapter,
“What’s in a Name?” Sufis in Iran experience hostility from Shiites because
of the latter’s belief that Sufism is related to Sunnism. Meanwhile, Western
perceptions of Sufism are of a sophisticated and enchanting sect of Islam. This description creates an allure but “up-close-and-personal observation,
if conducted in a noncommittal and unprejudiced manner, often results in
stripping Sufism of its aura of mystery and exoticism” (40) ...

Abstract 639 | PDF Downloads 431